A controversy within the Calvary Chapel movement has renewed a question Christians have debated for generations: Does Scripture permit women to serve as pastors, elders, and overseers in the church?

In November 2026, Char Brodersen, lead pastor of Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa, publicly explained his church’s practice of ordaining both men and women to pastoral ministry. He said that practice was not new. In two sermons, he appealed to the first-century setting of Ephesus and argued that Paul’s instructions about women teaching and exercising authority were aimed at problems in that church, not at every congregation in every age. Pastors affiliated with the Calvary Chapel Association objected, maintaining that Scripture reserves the pastoral office for qualified men.

This is more than a dispute within one church movement. At stake is a basic question of biblical authority: Will we allow Scripture to shape our understanding of church leadership, or allow our expectations of leadership to shape our reading of Scripture? We should consider the strongest arguments on both sides, distinguish what the Bible says from what we infer, and be willing to follow its teaching even when we do not fully understand God’s reasons.

Contemporary pastor instructing an ancient Ephesian congregation about women pastors

Why Ephesus Matters

Paul addressed his first letter to Timothy, his trusted coworker, whom he had instructed to remain in Ephesus, an important city in the Roman province of Asia (in present-day western Turkey). The letter was written to Timothy personally, but its guidance concerned the church's teaching, worship, and leadership in his care. Paul states the immediate problem in 1 Timothy 1:3–7: certain people were spreading false doctrine, pursuing myths and genealogies, and presenting themselves as teachers of the law. Later, Paul says he is writing so people will know how to conduct themselves in God’s household (1 Timothy 3:14–15).

Paul was no stranger to Ephesus. He first taught in the synagogue and later in Tyrannus's lecture hall, where his ministry continued for two years, reaching people throughout the province (Acts 19:8–10). When he later addressed the Ephesian elders, he warned that false teachers would arise—even from among their own number—and charged them to guard and shepherd the congregation (Acts 20:17–31). Timothy’s assignment fits that continuing concern.

Ephesus was also famous for the temple of Artemis. The goddess’s worship was woven into the city’s religious, civic, and commercial life. Acts 19:23–41 describes a riot stirred up by craftsmen who feared that Paul’s ministry threatened their trade in objects connected with Artemis. This background matters because Brodersen and other interpreters believe Artemis-related beliefs help explain Paul’s words in 1 Timothy 2.

The setting must be considered, but the distinction is crucial: the presence of Artemis worship in Ephesus does not prove that the women addressed in 1 Timothy were former Artemis worshipers or that Paul intended a temporary prohibition. Those further claims require evidence from the letter and from history.

Paul wrote his letter to Timothy from Macedona, probably Phillipi

Reconstruction using ancient sources and geography

What Does Scripture Mean by Pastor?

Churches today use the term pastor to refer to a role with diverse responsibilities, including youth ministry, worship, counseling, and administration. The New Testament, however, describes a recognized office responsible for the congregation’s spiritual oversight and sound teaching. Three words help clarify it: elder emphasizes recognized spiritual leadership; overseer emphasizes supervision and accountability; and shepherd, the word behind pastor, emphasizes feeding, guiding, and protecting God’s people.

These are closely related descriptions of the same essential leadership work. Paul called the elders of Ephesus and told them that the Holy Spirit had made them overseers to shepherd the church (Acts 20:17–28). Peter likewise instructed elders to shepherd the flock without domineering over it (1 Peter 5:1–3). In Titus 1:5–9, Paul moves from appointing elders to describing an overseer’s qualifications.

The issue, then, is not whether women can learn, teach in appropriate settings, lead ministries, or serve the church. Scripture shows that they can and do. The question is whether women are authorized to hold the governing and authoritative teaching office of elder or overseer. A modern title by itself cannot settle that question; the responsibilities of the office matter.

What Does Paul Actually Say?

The central passage is 1 Timothy 2:11–15. Paul first instructs women to learn, an expectation we should not overlook. Then he writes: “I do not permit a woman to teach or to assume authority over a man” (1 Timothy 2:12, NIV).

A major dispute concerns the Greek word authentein, translated “assume authority.” It occurs only here in the New Testament. Some scholars understand it to mean exercising authority; others argue that it implies taking control or domineering. That difference matters: a prohibition of abusive control would not necessarily prohibit legitimate pastoral leadership. Scholars also debate how the two activities—teaching and exercising authority—relate to one another. The grammatical wording more naturally coordinates two activities, but grammar alone cannot establish every detail of Paul’s intended scope.

We should neither dismiss these questions nor claim that one Greek word resolves the debate. The next verses matter because Paul supplies his own reason for the instruction: he appeals to Adam’s creation before Eve and to the events of the fall. We must account for that reasoning rather than replacing it with a theory about Ephesus.

Why Does Paul Appeal to Creation?

Paul writes that Adam was formed first, then Eve, and that Eve was deceived (1 Timothy 2:13–14). His appeal is significant because creation took place long before the problems Timothy faced in Ephesus. Yet the argument is more substantial than saying Adam happened to come first. Before Eve was created, God had already entrusted Adam with responsibilities.

Genesis 1:26–28 establishes that male and female are equally created in God’s image and share humanity’s calling to care for creation. Genesis 2 then provides further detail. God placed Adam in the garden to work and care for it, and gave him a direct command concerning the forbidden tree (Genesis 2:15–17). Work, stewardship, and moral accountability were therefore part of God’s good creation before the fall—and before Eve entered the picture.

God subsequently created Eve as a suitable helper and corresponding partner (Genesis 2:18–24). The Hebrew word ezer, translated “helper,” does not mean inferior; Scripture also uses it to describe God’s help for His people. Eve shared Adam’s human dignity and the calling to steward creation. Her arrival did not erase the responsibilities God had already given Adam.

When both disobeyed, God confronted each of them. Adam was condemned for his own disobedience, not explicitly for failing to prevent Eve from eating the fruit (Genesis 3:6–19). Yet Paul later identifies Adam, not Eve, as humanity’s representative in the fall and contrasts his disobedience with Christ’s obedience (Romans 5:12–19). Adam’s representative role means that his failure carried consequences beyond himself; responsibility before God involved accountability, not simply privilege.

We know relatively little about life before the fall, and Genesis does not say that being created first always gives someone authority over those created later. Neither does Genesis directly establish the New Testament office of elder. The connection to church leadership comes through Paul’s own appeal to creation, read alongside his instructions about overseers in chapter 3 and Titus 1:5–9.

Our conclusion is that Paul understood the creation arrangement as relevant to the responsibilities of the church’s governing teachers. This is a theological interpretation that must be defended on the basis of the whole passage, not an assertion that men are more intelligent, spiritual, or capable than women. The pattern concerns responsibility before God, not superiority over another person. We may not know every reason God established that pattern, but once His instruction has been rightly understood, obedience is our responsibility.

Does Artemis Change the Meaning?

Sandra L. Glahn’s book Nobody’s Mother examines Artemis of Ephesus and argues that this setting may illuminate Paul’s instructions, particularly the difficult statement about childbearing in 1 Timothy 2:15. Ancient evidence connects Artemis with protection and childbirth, although the cult’s practices varied and should not be reduced to a simple story of women controlling Ephesian religion.

One proposed interpretation is that some women had absorbed false teachings influenced by the surrounding religious culture. A related theory suggests that an alternative creation story, emphasizing female priority, could explain why Paul says Adam was formed first. This offers a possible local explanation, and serious scholars have argued for it. Historical setting can clarify Scripture, but a plausible reconstruction is not the same thing as a demonstrated fact.

The letter never identifies the women in 1 Timothy 2 as former Artemis priestesses, records no teaching that Eve preceded Adam, and does not say Paul’s restriction would expire after a particular group was corrected. Meanwhile, the letter’s references to myths, genealogies, and would-be teachers of the law (1 Timothy 1:3–7) provide clues that could point to both Jewish and pagan influences. Rick Strelan’s historical research offers reasons to take those alternatives seriously. None of this proves Artemis had no influence; it cautions against treating one disputed explanation as certain.

Verse 15 remains difficult, and Christians disagree about what “saved through childbearing” means. Whatever the answer, it cannot mean that women earn salvation by having children; salvation is God’s gift of grace received through faith (Ephesians 2:8–9). Nor can a proposed explanation of verse 15, by itself, settle the scope of verse 12.

The historical questions deserve careful study. But we should not use what may have happened in Ephesus to dismiss what Paul actually wrote—especially when he grounds his explanation in creation. History helps us read Scripture; it does not authorize us to replace explicit textual reasoning with unproven details.

Courtesy of Dallas Theological Seminary Voice

What About Women Who Ministered in Scripture?

The New Testament presents women as vital participants in the work of the gospel. Priscilla and her husband Aquila explained God’s way more accurately to Apollos (Acts 18:24–26). Paul commended Phoebe for her service and assistance to other believers (Romans 16:1–2). Junia was highly regarded among early Christians, though scholars differ on how to describe her relationship to the apostles (Romans 16:7).

Philip’s four daughters prophesied (Acts 21:8–9), Paul acknowledged women praying and prophesying (1 Corinthians 11:5), and he instructed older women to teach what is good (Titus 2:3–5). Any interpretation that denies women meaningful opportunities to learn, teach, and minister must reckon with these passages.

Nevertheless, exercising a spiritual gift is not identical to being appointed to the office of elder. Priscilla’s instruction of Apollos does not, by itself, establish that she served as an overseer; nor does a prophetic gift automatically confer governing authority over a congregation. At the same time, the absence of a specifically named female elder is not sufficient by itself to prove that none existed. The question must be settled by Scripture’s positive teaching about the office and its qualifications, not by overreading examples or arguments from silence.

Priscilla and her husband, Aquila, teaching Apollos in their Ephesian shop

What Qualifications Does Scripture Give?

Following his instructions in chapter 2, Paul describes the qualifications of an overseer in 1 Timothy 3:1–7. The leader must demonstrate godly character, self-control, hospitality, sound judgment, the ability to teach, and faithfulness in caring for his household. In Titus 1:5–9, the elder must also hold firmly to trustworthy doctrine, encourage others through sound teaching, and correct those who oppose it.

The qualifications are expressed in masculine language, including a phrase often translated “husband of one wife.” That phrase stresses marital faithfulness; it should not be treated as a command that every elder must be married, nor should masculine grammar alone carry the entire argument. Its significance lies in the wider pattern: Paul’s instructions concerning teaching and authority, his appeal to creation, the overseer qualifications, and the elder’s duty to guard doctrine.

Taken together, these passages provide, in our judgment, the stronger biblical case for entrusting the governing and authoritative teaching office of elder or overseer to qualified men. The conclusion is cumulative—not the claim that one undisputed word settles every interpretive question. And being male is never enough to qualify someone for pastoral office. A man without sound doctrine, integrity, and a servant’s heart is not qualified merely because he is a man.

Equal in Christ, Distinct in Responsibility

Galatians 3:28 teaches that distinctions of ethnicity, social standing and sex do not determine our standing in Christ. Men and women are equally united to Him through faith, equally recipients of salvation and equally heirs of God’s promises. This is not a future equality that awaits the kingdom; it is true of believers now.

That equality does not necessarily mean that every believer is assigned the same function. Paul pictures the church as one body with many parts and gifts (1 Corinthians 12:4–30). Different responsibilities need not imply different worth. The question is whether the particular distinction drawn in the pastoral texts remains binding for the present church.

Nor do present responsibilities tell us everything about the age to come. Paul says that now we know only in part, but one day we will know more fully (1 Corinthians 13:12). In the new creation, the curse will be gone, and God’s servants will reign forever (Revelation 22:3–5). Scripture does not describe exactly how those responsibilities will be assigned, and we should not pretend otherwise. Our equality in Christ is already real; we have yet to experience its fullness.

Jesus also made clear that leadership among His people must never imitate the world’s pursuit of power. He called leaders to become servants (Matthew 20:25–28), and Peter warned elders against domineering over those entrusted to them (1 Peter 5:1–3). Churches that defend male eldership while tolerating pride, coercion, or abuse contradict the very pattern of shepherding they claim to uphold. The same faithfulness that guards the elder’s qualifications must make room for the genuine gifts and ministry of women.

Our Response: Scripture Must Set the Standard

The question raised by Calvary Chapel Costa Mesa ultimately concerns more than a congregation’s practice. It concerns whether the church will submit its teaching and leadership to Scripture. Christians who disagree about women’s ordination are not automatically rejecting biblical authority; many sincerely seek to follow God’s Word and arrive at different conclusions. Their arguments deserve a fair hearing, and our own interpretation must remain open to careful examination.

Yet sincerity, tradition, popularity, and cultural approval cannot decide what Scripture means. Neither should archaeology or Greek scholarship be treated as though they could override the reasoning of the biblical text. Those resources are valuable precisely when they help us hear Scripture more faithfully.

After weighing the passages and the historical arguments, we conclude that the New Testament’s governing and authoritative teaching office of elder or overseer is entrusted to biblically qualified men. This is our reading of Paul’s instructions in their full biblical context, not a judgment that women are less gifted, knowledgeable, or spiritually mature. Their ministry is indispensable to the life of the church.

We should also resist making this disagreement a test of salvation. We are saved through Christ, not through perfect agreement on every question of church order. Nevertheless, a matter need not determine salvation to deserve careful obedience. Paul charged Timothy to guard the truth entrusted to him (1 Timothy 6:20) and required elders to hold firmly to sound doctrine (Titus 1:9).

We must neither diminish the women God has gifted for ministry nor redefine the qualifications for pastoral office simply because another arrangement seems preferable. Christ is the head of His church (Colossians 1:18). Our calling is not to make His design acceptable to us, but to understand His Word carefully and follow Him faithfully.

Prayer

❝

Heavenly Father, thank You for Your Word and for the church that belongs to Your Son. Forgive us when we read Scripture through our own assumptions instead of allowing it to correct them. Give us discernment to distinguish what You have revealed from what we have only inferred, humility when we disagree, and courage to obey what we come to understand.

We thank You for the women and men You have gifted to serve Your people. Help us honor every believer’s dignity and make faithful use of the gifts You have given. Raise up shepherds who love sound doctrine, reject pride and domination, and serve with the humility of Jesus Christ.

Guard Your church from false teaching and needless division. Keep us grounded in truth, generous toward one another, and eager to bring glory to Christ, the true Shepherd and Head of the Church. In Jesus’ name, Amen.

Sources

Primary contemporary sources

Biblical and historical scholarship